Are diverse candidates more likely to be hired through on-campus recruiting or online job postings?

The likelihood of diverse candidates being hired when applying through their college career service office compared to an online job board can vary based on several factors, including the nature of the industry, the specific job board or career service office, and the hiring practices of the employers involved.

College Career Service Offices: These are typically closely connected with the educational institution and may offer personalized support and resources to students, including diverse candidates. They often have established relationships with employers who are actively seeking to improve their diversity recruitment. These offices might host career fairs, networking events, and workshops that can facilitate direct interactions between employers and diverse candidates, potentially increasing their chances of being hired.

Online Job Boards: Job search sites like College Recruiter provide a wider reach, connecting candidates to a broader range of potential employers. This can increase the chances of finding job opportunities that align with a candidate’s skills and interests. However, the competition on these platforms can be higher, and the process is often less personalized. Some job boards may have specific features or initiatives aimed at promoting diversity, which can be beneficial for diverse candidates.

In both scenarios, the effectiveness in supporting diverse candidates also depends on the commitment of employers to diversity and inclusion. Companies that are proactive in their diversity recruitment efforts are likely to use both channels effectively to attract diverse talent.

Ultimately, the decision for a diverse candidate on whether to use their college career service office or an online job board may depend on their specific needs, the nature of their industry, and the support and opportunities provided by each channel. Employers looking to hire diverse candidates should consider leveraging both avenues to ensure a wide and inclusive reach.